nano-banana VS Qwen-Image-Edit VS Flux.1 Kontext

https://gyazo.com/48b71fc5beddafe698d77ad38a9bcfa8https://gyazo.com/1af335e010293bc3d1c5676ed654914ahttps://gyazo.com/540cc976298a87f159bdc98d3de344f5https://gyazo.com/2034b2ff5920bd6fa0af3434fd2cc2c9

https://gyazo.com/ecfe517a2bd1f1e9edb46f8c367afdebhttps://gyazo.com/7b30bb1cfbc246a053e77dff30387ca7https://gyazo.com/fc5c197cef9c3df3228a66b543bd921fhttps://gyazo.com/36c216a9bc12321318b00154fee38d6a

https://gyazo.com/d8d3e6a889da2a4d38ae7998ef32ec68

Flux.1は元のキャラを出してるけど鯨が雲になってなくて、プロンプトの忠実性だとnano-banana優勢基素.icon

Edit-R1-Qwen-Image-Edit-2509がなかなか強いmorisoba65536.icon

ポーズも変わってるし顔も違うしで、むしろ一番悪いと思っている…nomadoor.icon

https://gyazo.com/8ef3ddc228e18582669f1634df0c4af8

Please draw a cinematic scene of a woman applying makeup in front of a bathroom vanity.

https://gyazo.com/8e55a1a998e4c21c8105edac3f76d01fhttps://gyazo.com/82df8b928be4c280ccd6ebfd2229ce6chttps://gyazo.com/98f5d01c4e53061d549ffd0c5f321af9https://gyazo.com/f14ec73f6cfc00841bc69be48ca781ec

https://gyazo.com/8071acdcb8c7dfdf8a0b1a94d794c8f0https://gyazo.com/918b6acda0f17c6fa905e4d27c24a541https://gyazo.com/10d1e01d2200df9d4596787b9f01facahttps://gyazo.com/7110bb344250aa4f2313f0850f57e177

https://gyazo.com/f2f5e449a8bb7e6b6a39eeeab239a7c7

鏡のタスクはnano-banana以外シーンが破綻してる。bananaも左右反転してるし。難しいんだなぁ基素.icon

指示への忠実度はEdit-R1-Qwen-Image-Edit-2509がトップクラスに、ただ勝手に画風を変えたりしてるので参照元への忠実度という点ではbananaの方が維持してる感じ？(映画のワンシーン、で実写に引っ張られるなどが起きた可能性はあるが)morisoba65536.icon

https://gyazo.com/410f25c09fcc4506f6041f6385e273d4

Zoom out to show the entire woman's body.

The woman is looking at you, smiling and making a peace sign.

https://gyazo.com/b54449f92f52983d4f63d14d858bfe31https://gyazo.com/811127a519b2990e817ae8ac7b3abb47https://gyazo.com/8705a707f31d3158336fe6badf6fdf14https://gyazo.com/5cad3c3641732f69ea51ad1195b08e98

https://gyazo.com/ba689a5ea669e7fa47312bc0a9aab754https://gyazo.com/7b8738a333025b283275856efeffb3c8https://gyazo.com/76c6bd220f2241411835c406874e0e5chttps://gyazo.com/271d276400b558ce50854351884ecbd3

https://gyazo.com/d6ad2742f900ed3c200b910444bac903

https://gyazo.com/93a596f6dceb53429f63517603bd16a7

Please add color.

The background features a beautiful sea. The fur color is brown. It adopts a texture shading style reminiscent of Japanese anime.

https://gyazo.com/89d45967ec3cda75df8e38b840037363https://gyazo.com/a0d58ec55685d573d8325aeb5c42b618https://gyazo.com/d7deaf6968ce11a5aa51342497f4f949https://gyazo.com/9e631e90a945d8245890166f8ff955bf

https://gyazo.com/b9a1f5244b71cc0249f72ddb7e9e9c36https://gyazo.com/c7200ee0d86663bf00a62782b79dd603https://gyazo.com/77d86a84ab788133295d344fc7321fedhttps://gyazo.com/a5b65e628dc569046af5b1a25600df0e

https://gyazo.com/f8a26c767fbef38ebf7007452c216207

https://gyazo.com/21b1d762d0d26e75887f1db91223ce38

Dress this cat in Santa clothes and set it in a snowy landscape

https://gyazo.com/65da5806559fd09e492307d0e5904c5fhttps://gyazo.com/25a87a121eebaf56ccdf2e2a1d31f2c2(WIP)https://gyazo.com/fb7282cbe42530ba4d4fa0ae8f67ee75

https://gyazo.com/6d9931fe1f63d9d56c6ce281a2cf56c8https://gyazo.com/c1809a301c223f032c18dca1eb6464b4https://gyazo.com/39043386be14565cf6de01007893a4cahttps://gyazo.com/26e6e0544208c0824ef552e479038514

https://gyazo.com/89dc1b5b4da2792d41d2308c37c17b87

https://gyazo.com/683efcffd96474169767066776639a60

Replace "THE 1975" with "Aug 2025"

https://gyazo.com/aa365782cda88f06f1251d8def821cc3https://gyazo.com/3554a68030084c6f6afe53b553ad1295(WIP)https://gyazo.com/5bbc786587a0536eca6680c9d80f5f80

https://gyazo.com/6fe5e07317a990a006623ad396cb0acbhttps://gyazo.com/0f390ad77bb502e1ec06b3d9cf55d3fehttps://gyazo.com/1d7480693a3313b8d6b8cab7af4a631chttps://gyazo.com/e9e1d5778dcb93d006aff90a5bd01628

https://gyazo.com/607fb8c8a1ec8f42762b31bc32068ef6

https://gyazo.com/1f421a11eb7f46ffcf970787036c5cc1

remove the woman

https://gyazo.com/c80886b2726b2691e8d819aafa4c65a3https://gyazo.com/b9cdf4eaee01dbe92ea7a6691f1a3fe6(WIP)https://gyazo.com/0f8918eabf673402e4965008265ca0de

https://gyazo.com/d7e01d3f6a0ca3f9ea92f92c302a39cehttps://gyazo.com/a580e32145c8ecb054115a42dd30c635https://gyazo.com/974c60b385d0f5c070aad01dc8ea1108https://gyazo.com/6582404cf51f9ab5824fbf6578853371

https://gyazo.com/0d221a4a0430ce31cf7ed697adbd1dc1

Qwen-Image-Editさん単にコピペしてくれれば良い処理でも、書き直してしまうんだよなぁ…nomadoor.icon

この辺は一度vaeに圧縮してる点なども影響してるかも知れないmorisoba65536.icon

Nano BananaはGeminiのImagen 4のテスト版の時から元のフォント維持等は4o Image Generationよりも優秀だったので何らかの元イメージを維持するためのノウハウや事前処理を持っているのかも知れない(内部的にpixel処理してるとか)

もやし潜在拡散モデルじゃなくて、ピクセル拡散モデルなんですかね…🤔nomadoor.icon

割とその可能性はありそう(🦊Chromaの実験的なモデルでもpixel拡散を作れているので…)morisoba65536.icon

nano-banana全体的にpromptに忠実な感じだ基素.icon